Growing up and dying under the watch of social media (Surveillance and Social Media)

With the advent of social media as a normalised (and increasingly necessary) method of online existence, increasingly new parents are documenting their children’s lives online through their own profiles … and sometimes through profiles created for their children. This isn’t a new thing either: this was happening five years ago.

Perhaps it is time to ask what right children have to not have an online social media presence until they decide to – or has the time come when it is impossible to embrace anonymity even in the cradle?

Consider for a moment how Facebook commodifies the individual – that is that users have value to be bought and sold in targeting advertising sales. Lovink (2011 p.13) argues in ‘Networks without a cause’ that social media attempts to “extract value from every situation.”

Facebook as an organisation is incredibly adept at such analysis. That’s where the money is after all. Sometimes it is a little too adept for my own personal liking. How does Facebook know that I’m sad or happy? Good lord – how did Facebook know that I was hungry?!?! There is a much more invasive question that some female users have been asking themselves:

Some might say that this is a clever use of data analysis incorporating keywords, geolocation and behavioural patterns consistent with millions of users before them. Human behaviour after all, is repetitive. Sad as it is to say, we are not unique. Our lives converge in patterns … human behaviour has been said to be 93% predictable (, 2010) – you just have to look at things from the right perspective:

A section of the Mandelbrot set following a logarithmic spiral – infinite repetition (is human behaviour all that vastly different, really?)

Others might say that it is all a bit too invasive of privacy and overstepping boundaries. What we can say is this – it is not a paranoid delusion nightmare born out of reading too much Orwell and eating too much camembert as a late night snack. Data driven analysis is the reality of how Facebook’s economy works … we hand over this data to be surveilled daily.

Since Facebook was made public in 2006 there is now a generation on the verge of their teenage years who have never known world without Facebook. Do humans have a right to not be documented from the moment they are born? I don’t pretend to suggest that I have the answer to this question – the pervasiveness of Facebook in modern society has become so ingrained that it now serves for many online services as a digital passport required to engage in the discourse of the day:

Within in a couple of generations there will be individuals who have been born and died on Facebook. It is a probable outcome that AI with access to the Facebook database along with interconnected platforms will be able to track a person’s life from cradle to grave in incredible detail.

Private online conversations stored in the cloud (supposedly in a secure manner) long after we have passed will still contain this is sensitive and intimate information. This information is valuable: our loves, losses and our secret shames will all be open to access by whoever is the best hacker of the day. Bollmer (2013 p.147) poses these possibilities of what is beyond one’s control in the digital afterlife:

“Parts of the self one wishes to hide become exposed, acting counter to the will of the individual. These fears coincide with a discourse that equates these digital traces with the essence of human identity”

In the future one man’s hacker might be another’s man’s archaeologist and there is much information lurking underground to be had. Facebook is always watching.

After all, all this has happened before:

And all this can happen again:




Eye Contact ! by Craig Sunter (CC by ND 2.0)

Mandel zoom 04 seehorse tail by Dr. Wolfgang Beyer (CC BY SA 3.0)


Bollmer, G 2013, Millions Now Living Will Never Die: Cultural Anxieties About the Afterlife of Information, The Information Society, no. 3, p. 142. Available from: 10.1080/01972243.2013.777297. [01 August 2017].

Lovink, G 2011, Networks without a cause, Polity Press, Cambridge.

Physorg 2010, Human behavior is 93 percent predictable, research shows, retrieved 01 August, 2017,


4 thoughts on “Growing up and dying under the watch of social media (Surveillance and Social Media)

  1. Hi Antuua, great post overall! I like how you touch on the topic of privacy in relation to our online identity. It is true that the social media is eating away our personal privacy, and it would only become worse for the future generations, I agree that hackers are one of the main cause that is jeopardising the safety of our online identity. But we can’t deny the need for surveillance in the digital age, also the fact that it does help solve different society issues.
    By the way in the eighth paragraph, I think the “in” can be taken away, changing it into “Within a couple of generations”.


  2. This is a really interesting blog Antuua. The topic you have chosen is very intriguing and evokes a lot of deep thought for me. The correlation you’ve made between Facebook advertising and the predictability of humanity ties in well with the morality behind having children and even infants on Facebook and social media in general and poses a good ethical question about Facebook . I think the opening image of the eye under the heading is a great way to set the tone for the post.

    The sources you have used as well as your own twitter posts support your opinions well and love the scary yet realistic view that anonymity may be a luxury of the past. Great post Antuua!


  3. Hi Antuua, great post! I absolutely loved how you included the embedded tweets with links to relevant articles. This shows that you have thoroughly researched your topic and it allows me as a reader to dive into the topic as well. However, one thing you might want too watch out for is embedding too much tweets. The last half of your post kind of lost its flow for me due to the many embedded tweets. The images you added are also great, I love how you related the Mandelbrot to the predictability of humanity. Your writing style is easy to read but also professional and I did really enjoy reading the post overall!
    Cheers Lara


  4. Hi Antuaa!

    I really enjoyed reading this post! It is creepy how Facebook can accurately predict what our likes and dislikes are. It is concerning how some parents documented and published the growth of their children without thinking about the consequences in the future for both the parents and children. I love how you relate the repetition pattern of Mandelbrot to human behaviour.

    I gain a lot of information by reading this post. However, I suggest not to use too much embedded tweets in your post because I took some time to look into the links and then to your post back and forth. Try to include the summary of each link into your post.

    Overall, I find this post informative and easy to understand!

    I have this moment of realization when you said “one man’s hacker might be another man’s archaeologist.” And we are not far from there.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s